top of page

Beyond Tokenism: Why Fair Compensation for DEI Leaders is Crucial

As a seasoned leader in the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) space in Canada, I've witnessed firsthand the evolution of DEI roles within companies. I remember a time when these positions were virtually non-existent, and now, they're not only increasingly prevalent but also pivotal to an organization's success and moral fiber. This growth didn't happen overnight, and it certainly wasn't without its set of unique challenges.

The introduction of formal DEI roles in companies across North America can be traced back to several decades ago, with their prominence rising notably in the early 2000s. This emergence was not merely a trend; it was a necessary response to a growing recognition of systemic inequalities within organizations and the need for more inclusive work environments. A study by Dobbin and Kalev (2016) found that the appointment of diversity managers led to a notable increase in diversity among management between 1980 and 2010 in the U.S. However, despite these roles' increasing importance, one critical issue that companies often overlook is the fair compensation of DEI professionals.

Hiring best practices for DEI leadership roles involves several critical steps. It begins with the understanding that DEI leaders carry the significant responsibility of cultivating an inclusive culture, a task that requires a unique blend of expertise, empathy, and strategic vision. Thus, identifying candidates who possess not only the professional qualifications but also a deep, intrinsic commitment to DEI is paramount. Companies should prioritize lived experiences, leadership skills, and the ability to influence systemic change. Additionally, hiring panels should be diverse and include voices from the communities the DEI initiatives aim to support.

But beyond hiring, why is it supremely important to compensate DEI leaders appropriately?

Firstly, the complexity of DEI work is often underestimated. These roles are not 'add-ons' to organizations; they are drivers of fundamental cultural and systemic change. They require a deep understanding of historical and structural inequities, the skill to navigate sensitive interpersonal dynamics, and the ability to influence and drive strategic initiatives at all levels of an organization. This expertise is invaluable and should be recognized financially.

"DEI work is deeply transformative and fundamental to the very core of an organization. It's not just a job; it's a vocation that demands a high level of commitment, emotional labor, and unique expertise,"

says Kimberlé Crenshaw, an American lawyer, civil rights advocate, philosopher, and a leading scholar of critical race theory. Her work, especially in the intersectionality of race and gender, highlights the intricacies DEI professionals navigate daily.

Moreover, fair compensation for DEI leaders sends a clear message: the organization takes DEI seriously. It's a demonstration of an authentic commitment to the values of diversity, equity, and inclusion. When companies fail to compensate these leaders fairly, they risk undermining their DEI efforts. Employees are keen observers, and inconsistency between what a company professes and how it treats its DEI professionals does not go unnoticed.

The challenges of introducing a new role — especially one as impactful as this — into any industry are substantial. When the role also involves shifting an organization's culture, confronting deeply ingrained biases, and potentially overhauling longstanding practices, these challenges can seem insurmountable. It takes a courageous leader to undertake this, and bravery should be met with respect, which includes respectable compensation.

Lisa Rice, President and CEO of the National Fair Housing Alliance, encapsulates this sentiment perfectly:

"Compensating DEI leaders fairly is not just about paying an individual what they are worth. It's about investing in a vision of the organization as equitable, inclusive, and just. It's about valuing diversity, equity, and inclusion as fundamental principles rather than just performative gestures."

Reflecting on my journey, I can't emphasize enough the multitude of obstacles DEI leaders face. We are often tasked with pioneering an entirely new pathway for the organizations we serve, one that has never before existed in a meaningful way. We build bridges, foster understanding, and challenge the status quo, all while navigating the personal emotional toll this work can take.

As businesses continue to evolve and the global workforce becomes more diverse, the demand for DEI professionals will only grow. We are at a pivotal moment in history where companies have the opportunity to stand on the right side of it.

Compensating DEI leaders for their worth is not just a matter of fairness; it's a matter of integrity and a direct reflection of a company's commitment to real, impactful change.

3 views0 comments


bottom of page